Where to Order Thanksgiving Pies and Sides in the Omaha Metro

WheatFields Eatery & Bakery

Locations include: 1224 S. 103rd St. and 189th & Maple in Omaha

WheatFields has one of the more extensive Thanksgiving takeout options for 2026.

The menu includes:

  • Turkey dinners

  • Roast turkey breast

  • Mashed potatoes

  • Turkey gravy

  • House dressing

  • Sweet potatoes

  • Baked cranberries

  • Dinner rolls

  • Pumpkin pie

  • Pecan pie

  • Caramel apple pie

  • Other pie varieties

The Thanksgiving pre-order cutoff is Saturday, November 21 at 3 p.m.

Pickup is available November 23, 24, or 25, depending on the item and order.

One useful option is the boneless roast turkey breast, which serves approximately six to eight people. Sides can also be ordered separately.

If you're looking for both a main dish and several sides from one place, WheatFields is worth checking before the deadline.

A Catered Affair

Location: 8351 N. 134th Ave., Omaha

A Catered Affair is offering a Thanksgiving menu for 2026 that includes desserts and other holiday items.

Their Thanksgiving orders must be placed by 5 p.m. on Thursday, November 19, while supplies last, so this option has already reached its published deadline as of November 20.

Pickup is scheduled for Wednesday, November 25, from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.

If you missed the deadline, it is still worth keeping A Catered Affair in mind for future holiday catering.

Le Quartier Bakery & Café

Locations: 2505 S. 90th St. and 5026 Underwood Ave., Omaha

Le Quartier is another local option for Thanksgiving desserts.

Its 2026 Thanksgiving pre-order menu includes:

  • Pumpkin pie

  • Other holiday pies

  • Pumpkin roll cake

  • Macaron packs

  • Croissants

  • Additional pastries

Orders are listed as available through November 23 at 11:59 p.m., with pickup on Wednesday, November 25.

This can be a convenient option if you're looking for dessert without preparing a full Thanksgiving meal.

Vala's Thanksgiving Market

Location: 12102 S. 180th St., Gretna

For an option with a local fall feel, Vala's Thanksgiving Market is returning for 2026.

The market will be open at the Exit Barn on:

  • Tuesday, November 24

  • Wednesday, November 25

Vala's is known for its pies, including traditional favorites such as apple and pumpkin, along with other seasonal baked goods.

Online pre-orders are listed through November 22, although the published information contains an inconsistency about the exact cutoff day. Since November 22, 2026, falls on a Sunday, confirm the current deadline directly with Vala's before ordering.

For shoppers who prefer to choose their pie in person, the Thanksgiving Market is another option to consider.

Buttered Marshmallow

Location: 2515 N. 48th Ave., Omaha

Buttered Marshmallow is offering several traditional Thanksgiving pies for 2026, including:

  • Pumpkin

  • Pecan

  • Apple

  • Apple crumb

The pies are 9 inches and are priced between $30 and $35.

Pickup is scheduled for Tuesday, November 24 from 5 to 9 p.m.

This is a good option if dessert is the one part of Thanksgiving dinner you'd rather leave to a local baker.

Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop

Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop is also offering Thanksgiving pies for 2026.

The published holiday options include:

  • Traditional Thanksgiving pies

  • Vegan pumpkin pie

Pickup is scheduled for Wednesday, November 25 from 7 a.m. to noon.

The listed price is $32 for the regular pies and $35 for the vegan pumpkin option.

Because holiday quantities can be limited, confirm availability before placing your order.

Coneflower Creamery

Pickup: 1241 Millwork Ave., Omaha

If you want something a little different from a traditional bakery pie, Coneflower Creamery offers house-made ice cream pies.

2026 options include flavors such as:

  • Brown butter pecan

  • Pumpkin

  • Cherry

  • Sweet potato

  • Vegan/GF gingerbread

The pies are available for pickup at Millwork Commons on November 24 and 25 from noon to 10 p.m.

This could be a fun alternative if your Thanksgiving dessert plans don't have to follow the traditional pumpkin-pie route.

Ham on Rye Bakery

Ham on Rye Bakery is offering a Pomegranate Cranberry Mousse Pie for Thanksgiving 2026.

The listed pickup date is Wednesday, November 25 from 9 a.m. to noon, with delivery available upon request.

If you're looking for something beyond the standard pumpkin or pecan pie, this is one option to consider.

J. Gilbert's Omaha

If you would rather order more than just dessert, J. Gilbert's has a Thanksgiving takeout option for 2026.

The restaurant lists Thanksgiving dinner kits serving six for $240, with orders requested by November 23.

Thanksgiving dinner is also available at the restaurant on Thursday, November 26.

For homeowners who would rather spend Thanksgiving enjoying the day than preparing a large meal, a restaurant meal or takeout package can be another option.

What About Thanksgiving Sides?

If you already have the turkey handled but need help with the sides, look for options such as:

  • Mashed potatoes

  • Turkey gravy

  • Dressing

  • Sweet potatoes

  • Cranberries

  • Dinner rolls

  • Prepared vegetables

  • Mac and cheese

  • Other holiday side dishes

WheatFields is one of the more convenient choices because its 2026 menu allows customers to order individual side portions along with turkey and desserts.

Some restaurants and caterers also offer complete holiday meals that include several sides, which may make more sense if you're feeding a larger group.

Don't Wait Until Thanksgiving Morning

If you're planning to order something for Thanksgiving, check the deadline now rather than waiting until next week.

Many local businesses have deadlines between November 19 and November 23, while others have limited quantities.

Before placing an order, confirm:

  • Order deadline

  • Pickup date and time

  • Pickup location

  • Serving size

  • Whether the food comes hot or cold

  • Reheating instructions

  • Payment requirements

  • Cancellation or refund policies

This is especially important for prepared Thanksgiving meals because pickup windows can be much narrower than regular business hours.

A Few Local Options Have Already Closed

Since this guide is being published on November 20, some Thanksgiving pre-orders have already closed.

For example, Mealbox's published deadline was November 16, while A Catered Affair's deadline was November 19.

That doesn't mean you are out of options. Several Omaha-area businesses are still listing Thanksgiving orders or pickups for November 21 through November 25.

The key is to confirm availability before making plans around a specific menu.

Make Thanksgiving a Little Easier

Thanksgiving doesn't have to mean spending several days preparing every dish yourself.

Ordering one or two items from a local bakery or restaurant can save time while still giving your holiday table something special.

Maybe that's a pumpkin pie from a local bakery, prepared mashed potatoes and dressing, a full takeout meal, or an ice cream pie that becomes the unexpected favorite at dessert.

And if you're hosting in the Omaha metro, supporting local businesses is a nice way to keep some of your holiday spending close to home.

Final Thoughts

Whether you're spending Thanksgiving in Omaha, Papillion, La Vista, Gretna, Elkhorn, or another nearby community, there are plenty of local options for making the holiday meal easier.

Just remember that Thanksgiving pie and side orders can sell out before the holiday, and many businesses require advance ordering.

If you're new to the Omaha area and looking for more local recommendations, The Pierce Group can help you get familiar with the communities, businesses, restaurants, and neighborhoods that make the Omaha metro feel like home.

Visit PierceGroupNE.com to connect with Sarah and Bradley and explore more of the Omaha area.

Disclaimer:

Holiday menus, prices, availability, pickup times, and ordering deadlines can change. Information in this guide was checked against 2026 published listings and should be confirmed directly with each business before placing an order.

Next
Next

Buying and Selling With Kids at Home: How to Time Your Move Around the Omaha School Year